Business Strategy

5 min read

When to hire a social media manager, what to ask a freelancer or an agency before you sign, and how to judge the first month on what you actually get.

Hire a social media manager when the posting is already happening and the replies are not. If comments and messages sit for days while the feed looks busy, the account has outgrown the spare hour you give it. Then judge whoever you hire on the month you actually get, not on the pitch. The rest of this article is how to tell which kind of help you need, what to ask before you sign, and how to test the arrangement for a month before you commit to anything longer.

First, the honest case for not hiring anyone. Nobody knows the business like the people inside it. The owner who films a short clip at the counter, or the employee who knows every regular by name, will often make better content than an outsider with a nicer camera. If someone on your team enjoys it, posts most weeks and answers people the same day, keep it in-house and spend the money somewhere else. Outside help is for when the work has stopped fitting into anyone’s week.

It helps to see that social media is really three jobs. Making is the filming, the design and the captions. Posting is the calendar: getting the right piece out on the right day, on each platform, with the audio, tags and location it needs. Replying is everything after that: comments, direct messages, tags and mentions. Making gets the attention because everyone can see it. Replying slips first, because nobody sees an unanswered message except the person who sent it, and that person was often close to booking or buying.

There are three ways to get help. A freelancer is one person, usually strongest at one of the three jobs, and a good fit when you need a steady hand on the making or the posting and can keep the replies yourself. An in-house hire is inside the business all day and catches the moments nobody outside would see, but it is still one person covering three jobs, and you manage them. An agency brings a team, so planning, making and replying sit with different people, and you are paying for that coverage. None of the three is right for everyone.

Whichever you lean toward, ask the same four questions before you hire. Who makes the content, and do they need you on camera or on site to do it? Who replies to comments and messages, on which days, and how fast? What do you approve before it goes live, and what happens when you are slow to approve? What does the report show, and how often does it arrive? A good candidate answers all four without reaching for adjectives. If the answer to the reply question is vague, assume replying is not included.

For a reference point, here is what a managed month looks like with us. Burgama is a studio in Austin, and our Social Media Management is $2500 a month. That covers Reels and posts every week across Instagram, Facebook and TikTok plus a LinkedIn post, at least one Story every day, and a community manager on your accounts every weekday, with every comment and message answered within 24 hours. You approve a monthly content calendar, and nothing goes live without your sign-off. Our social work for Hush Hush Tan and MatchDay is published as case studies on our site.

One part of that month is worth explaining, because it is a fair test of whether a manager knows the platform. Instagram has a feature called trial reels. By Instagram’s own description, a trial reel is shown to people who do not follow you first, and your followers will not see it in their feed or the Reels tab unless you later share it with everyone. For accounts that have the feature, we post 3 a week, re-testing content that has already done well so it can reach new people with no new filming. Ask any candidate how they would use it.

Whoever you choose, treat the first month as the trial, whatever the agreement says. We recommend a first term of three months on our own retainers, and the first month is still where you find out. Before it starts, write down what you will check: how many pieces went out against the calendar you approved, how long comments and messages waited for a reply, and whether the report told you something you could act on. Read the account the way a customer would. A month is too short to judge growth and long enough to judge habits.

If the habits are there at the end of the month, keep going. If you spent week three chasing drafts, you have your answer, and it is better to have it early. And if the month shows that you only needed one of the three jobs covered, hire for that one. Plenty of businesses need someone to reply and nothing else. Sometimes the right hire is smaller than the one you went looking for.

Sources and further reading